Raw-Material Scarcity
Photo Credit: U.S. Department of AgricultureBy Thomas KolbeChina’s sharpest geopolitical weapon is an export ban on rare earths.

Intelligence Engine
China’s sharpest geopolitical weapon is an export ban on rare earths. Raw-material dependence makes the EU a plaything of other countries’ interests. Free trade offers a realistic way out of the trap -- an antidote to Brussels centralism.
Energy independence and abundant raw-material deposits are unquestionably among the most powerful geopolitical assets available to a country, a region, or a union of states. It is therefore unsurprising that, over the course of history, Europeans traveled far and wide to secure what they lacked: raw materials and precious metals.
Europe is an energy- and raw-material-poor continent and currently imports around 60 percent of its energy needs from other regions. And no matter how confidently the Union’s representatives strut across the international stage -- Ursula von der Leyen, Friedrich Merz, and their colleagues lost negotiating leverage at the very moment China launched its technological overtaking maneuver.
High energy costs, already unaffordable electricity prices, and looming gas shortages do not fall from the sky. They are the undeniable consequence of failed energy policy. Brussels miscalculated: from Germany’s nuclear phase-out to its delusional climate policy -- an attempt to deprive competitors of the advantage of using fossil fuels -- the entire strategy has failed. It is likely to rank among the greatest strategic errors of recent European history.
That Brussels nevertheless clings to its climate-policy stance is a phenomenon of power politics -- too many people profit handsomely from this redistribution mechanism. Yet the solution to raw-material and energy scarcity is obvious: free markets and free trade with equal partners. Yet free-trade agreements with resource-rich regions such as South America simply refuse to be translated into practice. Brussels blocks itself with its climate protectionism, to which only a few are still willing to submit.
The state should keep its hands off the market and confine itself to concluding trade agreements with resource-rich regions. This would, of course, also mean non-discriminatory access to the European single market -- without hidden protectionism through the European climate catalog.
Unfortunately, however, confidence in the market economy and its healing powers has eroded. European cultural Marxism has triumphed through the media and a wholly subjugated education system, settling like lead over society and the economy. The state is supposed to solve the very problems it creates. A curious logic, but nonetheless typical of modern central planners. In these circles, the market economy is regarded as an outdated concept, one that has, strangely enough, also been imbued with a nationalist tinge. Yet it is precisely the market economy that delivers what central planners botch. A few years ago, it was said that the West would eventually run out of lithium, cobalt, and nickel.
The energy transition and electromobility, it was claimed, would cause entire industries to fail because of the insufficient supply of these raw-material groups. That the energy transition is failing for other reasons -- massive subsidization and central planning -- is another matter.
Today, the balance sheet looks considerably more positive. Despite massive state investment, market forces have managed to resolve much of the problem. BloombergNEF’s Transition Metals Outlook 2026 concludes that nine out of ten of the raw materials examined are likely to have sufficient supply capacity through 2050. Copper remains the exception, where a substantial supply gap is emerging. The AI boom is materializing in rising raw-material demand, unless it is curtailed by the Democrats just elected in the United States.
The answer to high energy and raw-material prices is obvious: the price mechanism triggers investment. In recent years, price increases in scarce raw materials and important minerals such as cobalt, nickel, and tin triggered massive investment in mining activity. The financing of new projects, exploration, and the development of new mines has progressed well since then. Production volumes are rising.
The old stock-market adage applies: the best cure for high prices is high prices. High returns and margins attract fresh capital -- the market mechanism kicks in.
As if to prove this thesis, the price of cobalt, a raw material fundamental to the modern economy, fell by around 57 percent from its peak in May 2022 to approximately $33,500 per tonne by 5 November 2026. The same applies to nickel, which fell from almost $26,000 per tonne in 2022 to just over $16,000 most recently.
Market data are incorruptible; the argument cannot be dismissed: even the International Energy Agency confirms that this development is attributable to massive investment in new production capacity and an expansion of supply. What else, one might add.
Despite rising demand -- as the example of the cobalt market shows -- supply grew by around 25 percent over the past two years, while demand increased by about 10 percent. Technological substitution, efficiency programs, and new mining projects brought about the easing. We see that a functioning market mechanism can even turn feared scarcity into a surplus.
In the field of rare earths, the United States is likewise attempting to reduce its dependence on China step by step. The agreement concluded in September 2026 between Washington, Copenhagen, and Nuuk also covers cooperation on critical minerals and economic development. Here, there is undoubtedly a need for action: China currently controls around 90 percent of global refining capacity for rare earths. Understandably, the United States is seeking to break this dominance step by step through its own projects and new partnerships.
For Europeans, developments in the raw-material market mean that there is indeed a realistic way out of the scarcity problem. The key out of the energy-policy trap lies in participation in international trade. One would have to integrate into global value chains without imposing conditions that fragment the free market from the outset, as current climate policy does. This idea applies to metals just as it does to energy. Energy is, at its core, nothing other than the lifeblood of every industrial society -- indeed, of every society.
Yet those who consistently treat trading partners and political competitors with hostility and rebuff them with maximalist demands should not be surprised when electricity prices for industry in Europe are more than twice as high as in the United States and almost 50 percent above the level in China.
And Europe will have a hard time, in the long run, reintegrating Russia -- one of the world’s most important suppliers of raw materials -- into its own economy.
Read Full Intelligence Briefing
Access the complete report and original data sources from Americanthinker.com.
View Source Material

